The Lie Perfectionism Tells Us

88c67145 8241 47b9 a26d 77fe62c3a3e4

“The curious paradox is that when I accept myself just as I am, then I can change.”
Carl Rogers

“The most terrifying thing is to accept oneself completely.”
Carl Jung

I had a conversation recently about perfectionism.

The person I was speaking with said something I’ve heard many times before:

“If I wasn’t so hard on myself, I’d never get anything done.”

It’s such a common belief that many people never stop to question it.

Instead, they accept it as fact.

But my response was simple:

How do you know that?

Whose voice is that?

Who taught you that?

When did you first learn that criticism was necessary for growth?

Sometimes the most powerful question isn’t how do I fix this?

Sometimes it’s simply:

Why do I believe this in the first place?

Because many of us spend years, sometimes decades, living inside stories that we’ve never properly examined.

Perfectionism tells us that if we stop criticising ourselves, we’ll become lazy.

It tells us that if we stop demanding more from ourselves, we’ll stop growing.

It tells us that being hard on ourselves is the price of success.

But what if that’s not true?

What if the thing that’s keeping you stuck isn’t a lack of self criticism?

What if it’s the sheer amount of it?


The Lie

The lie perfectionism tells us is that we’re never good enough.

Not yet.

Not until we’ve achieved more.

Not until we’ve improved ourselves.

Not until we’ve fixed all the things we dislike.

The problem is that perfectionism never lets us arrive.

The goalposts keep moving.

There is always another flaw to fix.

Another standard to meet.

Another reason why today isn’t quite enough.

And while you’re chasing perfection, life is happening.

Joy is happening.

Relationships are happening.

Rest is happening.

But perfectionism rarely lets you enjoy any of it.

I’ve heard people describe it as exhausting.

Heavy.

Relentless.

I’ve heard people say exactly what was said to me recently:

“It’s stealing my happiness.”


Why Shouldn’t There Be Things Wrong With You?

This might sound like an odd question.

Most of us spend our lives asking:

“What’s wrong with me?”

Very few of us stop and ask:

“Why shouldn’t there be?”

Not because there is something fundamentally wrong with you.

But because you’re human.

You are a collection of experiences.

You learned things.

You adapted.

You developed coping strategies.

You found ways to survive difficult situations.

And many of those strategies made perfect sense at the time.

The problem is that what keeps us safe as children doesn’t always serve us as adults.

A coping mechanism can outlive its usefulness.

A protective strategy can become a prison.

The perfectionism that once helped you avoid criticism may now be criticising you every day.

The voice that once tried to protect you may now be the thing hurting you most.


What Rogers Understood

Carl Rogers believed something that many perfectionists struggle to accept.

He believed that change doesn’t begin with self rejection.

It begins with acceptance.

Not approval.

Not resignation.

Acceptance.

Acceptance sounds like:

“Of course I feel this way.”

“Of course I struggle with this.”

“Of course I’ve learned these patterns.”

“Look at what I’ve been through.”

That’s not making excuses.

That’s acknowledging reality.

And when we stop fighting reality, we finally have something solid to work with.


What Jung Understood

Jung recognised something equally important.

Acceptance is frightening.

In fact, he called it terrifying.

And I think many people know exactly what he meant.

To accept yourself means being willing to see all of yourself.

The confident parts.

The frightened parts.

The capable parts.

The messy parts.

The parts you’re proud of.

The parts you’d rather nobody saw.

That level of honesty requires vulnerability.

Real vulnerability.

And that’s why this work is so difficult.


A Different Question

Perhaps the question isn’t:

“How do I stop being a perfectionist?”

Perhaps the question is:

“What would happen if I stopped treating myself like a problem that needs solving?”

Not forever.

Just long enough to become curious.

Long enough to ask where these beliefs came from.

Long enough to wonder whether the voice in your head is actually yours.

Long enough to consider that being human was never supposed to mean being perfect.

Because perfectionism promises happiness after you’ve fixed yourself.

In my experience, happiness tends to arrive when you stop demanding perfection from a person who was never meant to be perfect in the first place.

Be curious, but be kind.

Phone
07856 606279
Email
jblaney@risepsychotherapy.uk
Location
117A Business First Business Centre, Empire Business Park, Liverpool Road, Burnley, BB12 6HH
Follow
© Rise Psychotherapy 2025