The Difference Between Feeling “Squirmy” and Feeling Unsafe: Why It Matters for Your Healing

Copilot 20260107 161634

Understanding Your Body’s Signals

One of the most common questions clients bring into therapy is:

“How do I know if I’m genuinely unsafe… or just uncomfortable?”

Your body can send similar signals in both situations, such as tightness, adrenaline, and a desire to pull away, but the meaning behind those sensations is very different. Learning to tell the difference between squirmy and unsafe is a crucial part of rebuilding self‑trust.


What “Squirmy” Really Means

“Squirmy” is the internal wriggle that shows up when you’re:

  • Trying something new
  • Being emotionally honest
  • Setting a boundary
  • Receiving healthy attention
  • Letting someone treat you well
  • Stepping out of an old pattern

Squirmy is discomfort, not danger. It’s your nervous system saying:

“This is unfamiliar… but not harmful.”

Psychologically, squirmy signals often show up when your growth edge is activated, when old beliefs about yourself are being challenged, or your comfort zone is expanding.

Personal Insight: I often tell clients that squirmy is growth, while unsafe is danger. For me personally, I notice squirmy when I delegate tasks instead of doing everything myself, or when I set a healthy boundary instead of defaulting to people-pleasing. That feeling is intense, almost like a wriggle under my skin, I want to shake off, but it doesn’t feel unsafe. It’s the nervous system noticing change, telling me: “You’re evolving; this is new.”

Mini Exercise: When you notice squirmy feelings, pause and label them: “This is discomfort, not danger.” Take three slow breaths and notice how your body responds. Over time, this practice strengthens your internal map of safety.


What “Unsafe” Feels Like

Unsafe is your body trying to protect you from:

  • Disrespect
  • Manipulation
  • Emotional volatility
  • Coercion
  • Boundary violations
  • Situations that echo past trauma

Unsafe is your nervous system saying:

“This reminds me of something that hurt me before.”

Unsafe situations shrink you. They silence you. They make you feel small or powerless.

Personal Insight: I distinguish unsafe from squirmy by noticing my body. Unsafe feels heavy and dark, like my heart drops into my stomach, a sense of doom washing over me. Squirmy, in contrast, is uncomfortable but almost playful. I can still function and move, but I feel that internal wriggle of growth. That awareness has helped me make clearer choices in relationships and boundaries. For instance, noticing squirmy allowed me to delegate more in life and accept help for growth without danger.

Tip: Notice if your body wants to pull away, tense, or freeze — these are protective signals, not something to override.


Why Trauma Blurs the Line

If you grew up in chaos, criticism, or emotional unpredictability, your nervous system learned to survive by constantly scanning for danger. That means:

  • Healthy intimacy can feel threatening.
  • Kindness can feel suspicious.
  • Stability can feel unnerving.
  • Being seen can feel overwhelming.
  • Boundaries can feel “mean”
  • Self-advocacy can feel selfish.

Your body isn’t wrong — it’s using an old map. Healing is about updating that map.

Reflective Prompt: Think of a moment recently when you felt uneasy around kindness or attention. Could this be your nervous system scanning for past danger?


How to Tell the Difference

Ask yourself:

  1. Does this situation expand me or shrink me?
    Growth feels stretchy. Danger feels constricting.
  2. Am I afraid of the situation, or afraid of being seen?
    Squirmy often shows up when you’re emotionally visible.
  3. Is this discomfort coming from the present or the past?
    If the reaction feels bigger than the moment, it may be an old wound speaking.
  4. Does this person respect my boundaries?
    Respect = squirmy. Disrespect = unsafe.
  5. If a friend described this situation, what would I say?
    Distance brings clarity.

Mini Exercise: When unsure, write down your thoughts in two columns: squirmy vs unsafe. Seeing it on paper often clarifies your internal signals.


How We Can Work on This in Therapy

In the therapy room, we can explore:

  1. Nervous System Literacy
    Understanding your body’s cues and patterns in real time.
  2. Somatic Grounding
    Techniques to regulate your body when discomfort or fear shows up.
  3. Rebuilding Self‑Trust
    Gently reconnecting with instincts to distinguish old fear from present‑day truth.
  4. Boundary Work
    Practising how to set boundaries in ways that feel safe, kind, and authentic.
  5. Reprocessing Old Conditioning
    Exploring where fear of judgement, rejection, or conflict originated, and loosening its grip.
  6. Developing a New Internal Map
    Creating a more accurate sense of what safety feels like, so you can recognise healthy relationships and environments.

Therapy becomes a space where you can experiment with being seen, honest, and yourself without punishment or pressure.


A Gentle Reminder

If you’ve spent years in survival mode, safety won’t feel like safety at first. It will feel unfamiliar. It will feel strange. It will feel… squirmy.

And that’s okay.

Squirmy is often the doorway to the life you’ve been trying to build. Unsafe is the signal to step back.

Learning the difference is not about perfection; it’s about compassion, curiosity, and slowly rebuilding trust in your own body.


Therapist’s Toolkit: 3 Bite‑Sized Strategies

  1. Squirmy vs Unsafe Pause
    When you feel tension in your body, pause for 10–15 seconds. Ask:
    • “Am I growing, or am I in danger?”
      Label the sensation as squirmy or unsafe, then take one grounding breath. This simple habit strengthens your internal radar.
  2. Boundary Check-In
    Before saying yes to a request or sharing something personal, ask:
    • “Does this feel expansive or constrictive?”
      Expansive = safe to proceed. Constrictive = time to step back or seek support.
  3. Mini Body Scan
    Close your eyes for a moment. Slowly notice:
    • Where your body feels tight or alert
    • Where it feels relaxed
    • Any areas of old tension
      Label the sensations without judgment. Over time, this trains your nervous system to notice real signals versus old trauma echoes.

Phone
07856 606279
Email
jblaney@risepsychotherapy.uk
Location
117A Business First Business Centre, Empire Business Park, Liverpool Road, Burnley, BB12 6HH
Follow
© Rise Psychotherapy 2025